In a list of best baseball ideas of the past 50 years, the Home Run Derby has to rank near the top.
What once was a mere sideshow to the All-Star Game's festivities has come to exist on the same plane as the event itself. The Derby submits for fans' consideration something that was true in the 1920s, 1950s and 1990s, and something that continues to be true in modern times: the majesty of the home run is like nothing else in North American sports.
It has created superstars—New York Yankees right fielder and designated hitter Aaron Judge's 2017 performance, for instance, put him on the pop-culture map. It has driven ratings in a barren portion of the sports calendar. It has done, consistently, for MLB what the Slam Dunk Contest once did for the NBA.
Styles of play are temporary, but since Cleveland Forest Citys third baseman Ezra Sutton hit the first big-league one on May 8, 1871, home runs have proven immortal.
Here's a look at the Home Run Derby's single-event and all-time record-holders for home runs.
Who has the most home runs in a single Home Run Derby?
That record is held by rookie Toronto Blue Jays third baseman and designated hitter Vladimir Guerrero Jr. during his 2019 coming-out party in Cleveland. Amazingly, in a quirk of the competition's bracketed format, Guerrero did not win—he would have to wait until 2023 to do that.
HOME RUNS
PLAYER
TEAM
YEAR
91
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Toronto Blue Jays
2019
82
Randy Arozarena
Tampa Bay Rays
2023
81
Julio Rodríguez
Seattle Mariners
2022
74
Pete Alonso
New York Mets
2021
72
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Toronto Blue Jays
2023
61
Julio Rodríguez
Seattle Mariners
2023
Giancarlo Stanton
Miami Marlins
2016
60
Joc Pederson
Los Angeles Dodgers
2019
59
Trey Mancini
Baltimore Orioles
2021
57
Pete Alonso
New York Mets
2019
Who has the most home runs in the Home Run Derby all-time?
No player in the 21st century has embraced the Home Run Derby quite like New York Mets first baseman Pete Alonso. Alonso bested Guerrero in that epic 2019 Derby and went on to win it again in the summer of 2021. Additional Derby trips in 2022 and 2023 have made him the most prolific home-run hitter in its history.
HOME RUNS
PLAYER
TEAM(S)
YEAR(S)
207
Pete Alonso
New York Mets
2019, ’21 to ’24
163
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Toronto Blue Jays
2019, ’23
142
Julio Rodríguez
Seattle Mariners
2022 to ’23
106
Albert Pujols
St. Louis Cardinals and Los Angeles Angels
2003, ’07, ’09, ’15, ’22
99
Joc Pederson
Los Angeles Dodgers
2015, ’19
Juan Soto
Washington Nationals
2021 to ’22
91
Todd Frazier
Cincinnati Reds and Chicago White Sox
2014 to ’16
83
Giancarlo Stanton
Miami Marlins
2014, ’16 to ’17
82
Randy Arozarena
Tampa Bay Rays
2023
81
Prince Fielder
Milwaukee Brewers and Detroit Tigers
2009, ’12
So far, two participants have been announced for the 2025 Home Run Derby: Atlanta Braves right fielder Ronald Acuna Jr. and Seattle Mariners catcher and designated hitter Cal Raleigh. Each will need to bash at least 57 home runs to crack the top 10 in a single derby, and two-time Derby participant Acuna needs at least 18 to break into the career top 10.